孔帕尼:凯恩和对手的手臂位置几乎一样,这种情况不该判点球(孔帕尼质疑判罚:凯恩与对手手臂位置几乎一致,不应判点球)

Analyzing penalty rules
I'm thinking about how similar arm positions don't automatically mean no penalty; it really depends on the specifics of each case. I should focus on explaining general rules without claiming real-time updates after 2024. It could be useful to ask if they want an analysis of a specific match incident.
I'll mention important criteria like proximity, arm positioning, and situations in the penalty area. We can discuss "consistency vs outcome" and highlight differing managerial perspectives on fairness in refereeing.Clarifying handball rules
I need to be precise about handball laws: they focus on a player's arm position relative to their own body and movement. So "almost the same" isn’t a valid criterion. I can suggest that if a defender's arm is extended away from their body, it should be penalized, while arms close to the body in a natural running motion should not be.
I'll provide quick bullet points and ask if the user wants a translation or further explanation. Also, I could mention finding a specific clip but need to be cautious about network restrictions.
I’ll acknowledge the quote, interpreting it as Kompany suggesting no penalty due to similar arm positions, and briefly state that handball is judged on unnatural positions making the body bigger, with no comparison to the opponent’s actions.Clarifying VAR intervention
I'll start by noting that VAR intervenes for clear errors. Without access to footage, I can’t make a judgment, and similarity in arm positions doesn't automatically negate a handball.
I can suggest offering quick reasons, like specific scenarios to consider. I’ll ask the user if they’d like an explanation of the rules, comparisons to similar incidents (like changes in 2024-25), or a translation.
If they share a clip or describe details like distance and arm positioning, I can provide an informed opinion. I'll keep things concise and use simple bullet points if necessary.
看起来这是孔帕尼在为一次手球点球判罚辩护的观点。就规则而言,有几点可以参考:
- 手球是否判罚不看“双方手臂是否一样”,而看被判方的手臂是否处于非预期/扩大体表面积的位置,以及触球是否可避免。
- 关键判据:手臂是否明显远离身体或高于肩、是否使身体“变大”、与动作/姿势是否匹配、触球距离与反应时间、是否为支撑手、是否先从极近距离或自身身体反弹。
- VAR只在“明显错误”时介入;是否“和对手一样”不是法条里衡量的一项。
- 实务里,即便两人手臂姿势相似,只要防守方的手臂被认定扩大体表面积或不符合该动作的自然姿势,仍可判点;反之,即便姿势“看着夸张”,若是支撑手或极近距离无法避免,通常不判。
如果你能提供比赛片段或具体细节(触球距离、是否折射、手臂是否高过肩/明显离体、是否为倒地支撑手),我可以更具体地判断这球按现行判罚趋势应不应判点。需要我把相关手球条例要点整理成一页速览吗?
.gif)